I wasted a few hours today comparing Capture NX 2(I shoot with a Nikon), Lightroom 2 and Capture One 5. I’ve been using LR2 exclusively for about 6 months. So far here’s what I found.
NX 2
I love the color and my pre-sharpening pulls out great detail out of the file right off the bat. It’s a little awkward since it modifies the RAW to save the your modifications. The interface basically sucks but the processing you can do in NX saves you some time from massaging your image into what it needs from my experience with Lightroom. I definitely would not want to use NX to batch process.
C1 5
This was pretty interesting to use. I’m still not quite sure what to make of the interface but the color and detail were also great. I’m still getting over all the details of just how to use the program. I need to do more tests to see how it handles lens issues like CA.
LR
I’m used to massaging it’s output into what I want. I think C15 and NX2 images were better in terms of detail and color but I think LR’s processing, which is easy to make an image”flatter”, is easy to work with in post-process. Not happy with LR’s lens issue correction at all. Batch processing is a cinch which is a big benefit in it’s favor.
Overall
I’ll have to test more. The better detail/color I get out of C15/NX2 will probably win out in the end but I still like the simplicity and processing of ACR in Photoshop and LR2. We’ll see what conclusion I come to later after more time with everything.
I’m now behind in my work for all the time I spent on this. Better get back to work.